Florida Minister’s Killing Could Be A Case Of Mistaken Identity

Akeem Moore was a musician, preacher and aspiring divinity graduate whose ministry reached beyond the church walls. His family is seeking justice after his shooting death, even as new details emerge about a possible motive. Credit: Akeem Moore/Instagram

by Rev. Dorothy S. Boulware

Even after he was shot, Akeem Moore was trying to save someone else’s life.

The 31-year-old Florida worship minister, mortally wounded when a gunman opened fire on his car, managed to drive himself and his passenger to a nearby fire station. Moore died at a hospital, but his passenger survived.

Now, more than a month after the killing, a Palm Beach County grand jury has indicted Hugh Earp Milner Jr. on first-degree murder and other charges. Police believe Milner may have mistaken Moore’s passenger for his former girlfriend, making the death of the beloved preacher and musician an especially tragic case of apparent mistaken identity.

- Advertisement -

For Moore’s family, the indictment is a step toward justice, but it cannot explain away the loss of a young minister whose life revolved around faith, music and service.

Authorities arrested Hugh Earp Milner Jr., 38, in Broward County. He faces charges of first-degree murder with a firearm, attempted first-degree murder with a firearm and shooting into an occupied vehicle. Authorities have not publicly established a motive, but have called it a possible case of mistaken identity. 

For Mount Calvary, Moore’s death leaves a silence at the organ and a gap in the work he shared with others. Earl Harris, a maintenance worker at the church, told WPTV⁠ that Moore brought different songs to the choir and strengthened its Sunday music. The church remembered his dedication to study, preaching, and service. 

His reach extended beyond Mount Calvary. Pastor Bryce Graham of Anointed House of Prayer Ministries told news station WPBF⁠ that he and Moore became friends through their shared faith. Graham recalled Moore’s music and preaching, as well as his community outreach and care for grieving families. 

- Advertisement -

Moore’s older brother, Tyquaris Dudley, told WPTV that he admired and looked up to Moore. 

Webb said the family wants people to remember how Moore ministered, served and loved. Those memories now sit beside an unanswered question about his death. 

Must Read

The Seattle Medium’s 2026 General Election Endorsements

The Seattle Medium releases its 2026 general election endorsements ahead of the Nov. 3 vote, recommending candidates for Congress, the state Legislature, King County offices and the courts, while urging voters to reject two state ballot initiatives concerning parental rights and K-12 athletics participation requirements.